Phase separation of a gas-liquid-solid mixture

ABSTRACT

A method for improved separation of liquids, gases and particulate solid materials in a liquid gas contacting process wherein a liquid feed and gas usually hydrogen are passed upwardly through a bed composed of a particulate contact agent, the velocity of the gas and the liquid being such that the particles are put in a state of random motion and the volume of the bed is expanded over its static volume and wherein an area of high liquid gas and liquid turbulence and mixing is created and wherein liquid effluent and gaseous effluents are removed from the contact zone. The method consists of effecting essentially complete disengagement of the gas from the mixture of particulate solids and liquid. The gas-free liquid-solid mixture is then introduced to a zone of relatively low turbulence and liquid is then removed from this zone at a rate whose lineal velocity is less than the settling velocity of the solid, thereby allowing substantial settling of the solid and resulting in the removal of a clarified liquid. The disengaged gaseous effluent may then be removed separately or recombined and removed with the liquid effluent. Apparatus for efficiently carrying out this process are described.

United @tates Patent [72] Inventors Carl L. Weber Washington Crossing, Pa.; Ronald 111. Wolk, Lawrence Township, Mercer County; Michael C. Chervenak, Pennington, NJ. [21] Appl. No. 737,156 [22] Filed June 14, 1968 [45] Patented Nov. 23, 1971 [73] Assignee Hydrocarbon Research, Inc.

New York, N.Y.

[54] PHASE SEPARATION OF A GAS-LlQUID-SOLID MIXTURE 2 Claims, 7 Drawing Figs.

[52] US. Cl 23/11 23/288, 196/46, 208/108, 208/213 [51] Int. Cl C0lg 1/00, CIOg 13/18,C10g 23/06 [50] Field of Search 208/213, 216, 208, 209,157; 196/46; 23/1 F, 288.3 E

[56] References Cited UNITED STATES PATENTS 3,003,580 10/1961 Lanning 208/157 2,468,508 4/1949 Munday 23/1 F 2,892,773 6/1959 Hirsch et al..... 208/213 3,124,518 3/1964 Guzman etal.. 208/213 a LIQUID AND GAS 3,151,060 9/1964 Garbo 3,188,286 6/1965 VanDrieSen ABSTRACT: A method for improved separation of liquids, gases and particulate solid materials in a liquid gas contacting process wherein a liquid feed and gas usually hydrogen are passed upwardly through a bed composed of a particulate contact agent, the velocity of the gas and the liquid being such that the particles are put in a state of random motion and the volume of the bed is expanded over its static volume and wherein an area of high liquid gas and liquid turbulence and mixing is created and wherein liquid effluent and gaseous effluents are removed from the contact zone. The method consists of effecting essentially complete disengagement of the gas from the mixture of particulate solids and liquid. The gas-free liquid-solid mixture is then introduced to a zone of relatively low turbulence and liquid is then removed from this zone at a rate whose lineal velocity is less than the settling velocity of the solid, thereby allowing substantial settling of the solid and resulting in the removal of a clarified liquid. The disengaged gaseous effluent may then be removed separately or recombined and removed with the liquid effluent. Apparatus for efficiently carrying out this process are described.

GAS

LIQUID PHASE SEPARATION OF A GAS-LIQUID-SOLID MIXTURE BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION This invention pertains to the field of separation of gases,

. More particularly, it

and compounds of metals selected from groups Vlb and VIII of the periodic table. The preferred conditions for carrying these type processes are temperatures in the range from about 600 F. to about 900 F., pressures in the range of from about 500 to about 5000 p.s.i.g., and space velocities greater than about 0.25 v f/hrs./V.,

particularly with respect to increased distillate yields, longer periods of operability, improved temperature control and temperature uniformity across the reaction zone, increased catalyst life, etc.

A major characteristic of these systems is that while there is bed expansion and turbulent intermixing of the phases within the reaction zone, most of the tend that the larger extrudate type solids are used predominately in the commercial systems now in use or being designed.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION We have discovered that a substantial reduction in the amount of solids carryover in the liquid effluent of the systems described above, can be achieved by first disengaging or sequence of additional solids carryover.

We have found that in powdered solids ebullated systems, a major portion of the solids are retained in a zone with little change in solids concentration from the bottom to the top. Above the zone, however, a concentration gradient exists wherein the concentration of solids decreases as the effluent exit is approached.

While a total effluent, i.e., gas and liquid products combined, may be removed and subjected to separation external highly turbulent state at the point of liquid removal due to, first-the relatively high liquid velocities in that area, second-the continuous and profuse bubbling of gas through the liquid. Thus, a truly random mixture of liquid, gas and solid exists.

Once the gas has been removed, however, turbulence of the liquid is decreased to a level where the density difference between the solid and the liquid can effect settling. We have discovered that this level of turbulence exists when removing the solids-free liquid from the gas free dilute slurry at a rate less than the solids settling rate. Usually, it is most desirable to confine the dilute slurry in a zone away from that containing settling to be obtained as described above, recombined with the solids free liquid prior to removal. We have found a method and apparatus for carrying out that method whereby the recombination of the gas and solids free liquid produces insignificant turbulence such that the recombination does not disturb the solids settling process.

Particularly, the apparatus of our invention gives minimum solids carryover when used in combination with high pressure reaction vessels which are adapted for reacting liquid feed materials with a hydrogen-rich gas at high temperatures and pressures. These vessels usually have means for withdrawal of liquid and gaseous effluents and the disengaging apparatus is normally affixed in the upper portion of the reactor.

DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING FIG. 1 is a partial vertical cross section and schematic of a reactor containing a disengagement apparatus for separate removal of gaseous and liquid effluents.

FIG. 2 is a perspective view of a disengagement apparatus for separate removal of gaseous and liquid effluents.

FIG. 3 is a partial vertical cross section and schematic of a reactor containing a disengagement apparatus for removal of a total effluent.

FIGS. 3A, 3B and 3C are partial vertical cross sections of various modifications of the total effluent exit pipe of FIG. 3.

FIG. 4 is a graph comparing catalyst retention as a function of time for various types of separation devices and the disengagement process and apparatus of the invention.

DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT The inventive concept of our discovery is illustrated and delineated in the drawings as follows:

FIG. I shows a typical high pressure reaction vessel and the placement of the disengagement apparatus as described hereafter in said vessel. Processes of the type utilizing our invention may be described as follows. A liquid feed material at E2 is fed together with a gas, usually hydrogen, at through line 14 and into reactor 16, which contains a bed of particulate solids 18 and the disengagement device which is held in place by support members 20. The solids may have a narrow size distribution within the range from about 20 to about 325 mesh on the US. scale, or may be in the form of extrudates having diameters between one thirty-second and one-eighth inch.

The gas and liquid feed are passed upwardly through the bed to expand it and place the particles in random motion. A disengaged gas space 32 exists at the top of the reactor and the remainder of the reactor. volume below interface 26 is filled with the turbulent gas-liquid-solid mixture. This mixture is continually swept past gas disengagement surface 22. The gaseous bubbles impinge upon this surface and because of the obliqueness of the surface, are directed upwardly and outwardly towards the wall of the vessel. The gas passes up through the gas mixture interface 26 to space 32. Surface 22 essentially acts to disengage the gas from the mixture since it directs the gas away from dilute slurry entrance 241. The gasfree dilute slurry is swept into dilute slurry entrance 24 by the turbulent forces and velocities within the reactor and thereby enter settling chamber 25. The liquid-solid slurry contained within the chamber is substantially out of contact with the highly turbulent zone, i.e., except for the contact established through the dilute slurry entrance. As a result of the relative calm of the slurry contained in settling chamber 25, the particulate solids contained therein settle at a rate which is dependent upon the relative density of the solid to the liquid, the particle size of the solids, the viscosity of the liquid, and the upward liquid velocity in the chamber. The settled particulate solids leave the chamber as a concentrated slurry through exit and enter the turbulent zone. The solids-free liquid effluent is removed through exit 28 from the reactor and the gaseous effluent is removed through line 34.

It is important to note that the main parameter affecting the ability of the solids to settle is the turbulence of the area around the solids and not necessarily the liquid velocity per se. Thus, by removing the gas from the mixture prior to solids settling, it is possible to remove the liquid effluent from the settling chamber at a velocity equal to or greater than the liquid velocity within the reaction system itself. It is only necessary that this settling chamber velocity be less than the settling rate of the solids.

The disengagement device discussed above is for use when it is desired to remove the gaseous and liquid efiluents separately. As shown in FIG. 1, this device consists first of a gas disengaging means 22 usually being constituted by a baffle or sheetlike surface having relatively large cross-sectional area to induce a deflective force to the bubbles. In the case shown, a funnel type member is most convenient and suitable for this purpose.

The settling chamber 25 has a lower portion in the shape of truncated cone with the wider end upward and an upper portion having a cylindrical shape. An exit pipe 28, opens perpendicularly into the top of the chamber. While the drawing shows a continuous necking down from the cylindrical portion to the pipe, this is not a critical requirement in this modification. The lower part of the chamber is partially inserted into the top of a cone-shaped member 22, but is spaced from the inner side of the cone 22 to leave an annular passage which acts as the dilute sluny entrance. The cone has a hollow stem attached to the bottom such that the stem constitutes the concentrated slurry exit.

Numerous modifications may easily be devised with respect to the design and formation of the device. The main requirements of the chamber is that it have a dilute slurry entrance or entrances and an exit for removing solids-free liquid and an exit for removing a concentrated slurry resulting from the settling of the particulate solid. In the device shown, the upper cylindrical member is affixed to the lower funnel member by connecting and support means which are not illustrated for the sake of clarity. It is not necessary, of course, that the slurry entrances be a continuous opening, but may be simply separate apertures leading to the interior of the settling chamber or tangential openings.

The device must also have means to direct the disengaged gas away from the dilute slurry entrances. This is most easily accomplished as shown by having the disengaging surface directed away from the dilute slurry entrances. In the case, however, where the disengaging means is separate and apart from the device as a whole, it is relatively easy to design the disengaging surfaces so as to direct the disengaged gas away from the dilute slurry entrances. Of course, it is possible, if desired, to have separate disengagement and directing means.

FIG. 2 shows a second mode of embodiment of the device and illustrates the manner in which the above-mentioned basic components may be incorporated into another design. Here, the device consists of a cylindrical zone 38 which constitutes the settling chamber having a solids-free liquid exit 40 at the top and a concentrated slurry exit 42 at the bottom and dilute slurry entrances 44 circumferentially disposed about the middle of the cylinder. A beveled lip 46 is attached to the cylinder just below the dilute slurry entrances, which completely circumscribes the circumference of the cylinder, said lip forming an acute angle with respect to the cylinder surface such that it would direct any impinging gas bubbles which has been disengaged by the lower surface of the cylinder away from the dilute slurry entrances. Thus, while many particular designs of the disengagement device are possible, in order to achieve the desired result, only those basic components as described are necessary.

FIG. 3 shows a device in a reaction vessel where the liquid and gaseous effluents are removed from the vessel together. This device differs from that shown in FIGS. 1 and 2 only in that it has an inlet 27 in the upper portion of the chamber, i.e., that portion which is above the gas liquid interface 26. This inlet in the case shown is formed simply by leaving the top of the settling chamber open. Other variations are apparent such as having slits, apertures, etc. in the upper portion of the chamber. It is only important that the inlet be sufficiently large so that the gas easily enters the chamber.

The manner in which the gas is directed away from the dilute slurry entrances 24 has been described heretofore. The disengaged gas bubbles pass through interface 26 and into the gas space 32. The disengaged gas then freely enters the chamber through gas inlet 27. Thus, a gas liquid interface 48 is formed within the chamber. As a result of the density difference in the fluids in the two zones, the level of interface 48 is lower than that ofinterface 26.

Solids-free liquid is withdrawn through exit tube 50 from chamber 25 at a rate such that the linear velocity in chamber 25 is below the solids settling rate. Tube 50 extends into chamber 25 and its lowest point determines the level of interface 48 with the overall result that a mixed, total effluent of gas and liquid is removed through tube 50.

Ordinarily, it will be found that the gas in zone 32 will tend to depress interface 43 and permit gas to enter the end of tube 50. Thus, the flow of liquid and gas is self-regulating and a uniform, continuous flow of gaseous and liquid effluents is removed through tube 50.

Additionally, we have found that a smoother flow of gaseous and liquid effluents through tube 50 can be obtained by adapting the lower end of said tube with traverse openings with several levels of entrance into the tube such that gaseous efiluent may pass directly through the openings into the exit tube. Various modes of such openings are shown in FIGS. 3A, 3B and 3C.

Particularly, FIG. 3A shows tube 50' having a beveled opening whereby a portion of the opening is available to the gaseous efiluent at all times even with fluctuations in the level of interface 48. FIG. 3B shows tube 50" having a slotted opening and FIG. 3C shows tube 50" having a plurality of vertically spaced holes.

While the dimensional relationships of the disengagement device to the internal volume and diameter of the reaction vessel are not critical, there are preferential dimensions which are described below. Theoretical and practical considerations require that the diameter of the device be sufficiently less than the diameter of the reactor such that the annular space between the outside of the disengagement device and the inside wall of the reactor is large enough to allow liquid slurry and gas mixture to easily pass through the space without resulting in extraordinarily high gas-liquid velocities. Naturally, the liquid velocity in the annular space will be greater than that in the reactor segment contained below the disengagement device, since the feed rate and withdrawal rate remain constant. Particularly, we have found that improved flow into the dilute slurry entrance can be efiected by having the diameter of the cylindrical portion of the chamber not less than the greatest diameter of the cone. While the dimensional relationships of various components of the device to one another are not critical to the operation of the device, such relationships may be optimized extracting maximum efiiciency. Once the basis mechanism of our invention is understood,

however, such optimization is simply a matter of experimental determination.

Example I gives the details of the conditions used for the comparison shown in FIG. 4. The only difference between each of the runs shown is the type of device used. FIG. 4 shows graphically a comparison of the solids bed retention obtained with the process of the invention using both type devices as described above and other types of disengagement devices. The particular devices compared in FIG. 4 are as follows:

1. cones -a 2-inch and 5-inch cone which consists essentially of a funnel with a maximum cone diameter as designated. In one case, the 5-inch cone had a l6-mesh screen below the cone to alter gas bubble speed and size.

2. 3 vertical rods-the use of vertical rods has given advantageous results for gas disengagement in fluidized systems, i.e., systems containing only gas and particulate solids. In the case shown, however, it is demonstrated that such mechanism does not operate to advantage in the ebullated bed system.

3. liquid cyclone.

As shown in FIG. 4, the particulate solids loss from the bed was only about 7 percent of the bed per hour of operation when utilizing the separation devices and process of the inven tion. The next best device, the cyclone, lost 50 percent of the bed in the first hour of operation with the percentage loss diminishing as more of the bed passed overhead.

In addition to the processes heretofore described, out invention is uniquely applicable to multiple stage systems which have been found to give certain advantages with respect to increased yields of products and improved operability. It is usual, for instance, to incorporate two or more reaction zones in series with the total effluent from each going to the next subsequent reaction zone. Alternately, multiple stage systems have been operated wherein the gaseous and liquid effluents are removed separately from each stage and only the liquid effluent is passed onto the next subsequent stage with the gaseous effiuents from each stage being combined and treated as a reaction product. A third modification is the removing of a total, combined gaseous and liquid effluent from the first stage, introducing this to the second stage and removing separate gaseous and vaporous efifluents from the second stage. This particular combination has resulted in somewhat superior sulfur removal when used in a hydrodesulfurization of a petroleum residuum feed material.

Generally, the use of our invention gives substantial advantages in multiple stage catalytic systems because of the absence of contaminated catalyst carryover into the next subsequent stage.

Thus, we have discovered a unique method for reducing the solids carryover in a system utilizing the ebullated bed contacting method. At the same time, we have discovered a device which allows one to carry out the method of our invention with great convenience and efficiency. It is understood, of course, that while in the example cited above, the results given are those for an experimental size unit, they are applicable in all respects to commercial size units, said application being only a matter of engineering scale-up.

While we have shown a preferred form of embodiment of my invention, we are aware that modifications within the scope and spirit of our invention will occur to those skilled in the art, and such modifications are contemplated to be within the scope of the claims appended hereinafter.

We claim:

ii. In a process for continuously contacting liquid, gas and particulate solids in a reaction zone wherein the liquid and gas are passed upwardly through a bed of said particulate solids contained in the reaction zone and wherein the velocities of the liquid and gas are such that the bed expands to a volume at least l0 percent greater than its static volume and the particulate solids are in a state of random motion in the reaction mixture and wherein the velocities of liquid and gas are regulated to provide an interface between said reaction mixture and said gaseous effluent discharging from said mixture and wherein liquid and gaseous effluents are removed from the reaction zone with some carryover of said particulate solids in said liquid effluent, the improvement which comprises:

a. minimizing the carryover of particulate solids in said liquid ef'fluent by first disengaging gaseous effluent from the gas-liquid-solid mixture below the interface to produce disengaged gas and dilute slurry;

introducing the gas-free dilute slurry to a solids separation zone contained within the reaction zone but wherein said dilute slurry is substantially out of contact with the gas-liquid-solid mixture in the reaction zone;

c. removing a substantially solid-free liquid effluent from said separation zone at a rate whose linear velocity in the separation zone is less than the settling rate of the solids of the dilute slurry in the separation zone;

. settling the solids out of the dilute slurry to form a concentrated slurry in the lower part of the separation zone;

. removing said concentrated slurry from said separation zone and returning the slurry to the reaction zone; and

f. combining said substantially solid-free liquid with said gaseous effluent and removing them together as a combined effluent from the upper part of said reaction zone.

2. In a process of continuously contacting liquid, gas and particulate solids in a reaction zone wherein the liquid and gas are passed upwardly through a bed of said particulate solids contained in the reaction zone and wherein the velocities of the liquid and gas are such that the bed expands to a volume at least 10 percent greater than its static volume and the particulate solids are in a state of random motion in the reaction mixture and wherein the velocities of liquid and gas are regulated to provide an interface between said reaction mixture and said gaseous effiuent discharging from said mixture and wherein liquid and gaseous effluents are removed from the reaction zone with some carryover of said particulate solids in said liquid efiluent, the improvement which comprises:

a. minimizing the carryover of particulate solids in said liquid effluent by first disengaging gaseous effluent from the gas-liquid-solid mixture below the interface to produce disengaged gas and dilute slurry;

. introducing the gas-free dilute slurry to a solids separation zone contained within the reaction zone, said separation zone comprising a vessel having a closed upper end with a discharge conduit from said end for passing liquid efiluent to the exterior of said reaction zone, an opening in the bottom of said vessel for passing said gas-free dilute slurry into said vessel;

. removing a substantially solid-free liquid efiluent from said operation zone at a rate whose linear velocity in the separation zone is less than the settling rate of the solids of the dilute slurry in the separation zone;

. settling the solids out of the dilute slurry to form a concentrated slurry in the lower part of the separation zone;

. removing said concentrated slurry from said separation zone and returning the slurry to the reaction zone; and

f. separately removing gas from the upper part of said reaction zone and liquid effluent from the vessel through the discharge conduit out of the reaction zone.

UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE CERTIFICATE OF CORRECTION Patent No. 3,622, 265

D te November 23. 1971 Qanl Ll me et all It is certified that error appears in the above-identified patent and that said Letters Patent are hereby corrected as shown below:

Column 1, lines 35-36, "V /hrs./V. should be V /hr/V lines 67-68, "extend" should be extent Column 4, line 59, "has" should be had Column 7, line 2, "operation" should read separation Signed and sealed this 24th day of October 1972.

(SEAL) Attest:

EDWARD M.FLETCHER,JR.

ROBERT GOTTSCHALK Attesting Officer Commissioner of Patents USCOMM-DC BO376-P09 s u s covimmsm PRINTING OFFICE 1 '9" o-ass-su 

2. In a process of conTinuously contacting liquid, gas and particulate solids in a reaction zone wherein the liquid and gas are passed upwardly through a bed of said particulate solids contained in the reaction zone and wherein the velocities of the liquid and gas are such that the bed expands to a volume at least 10 percent greater than its static volume and the particulate solids are in a state of random motion in the reaction mixture and wherein the velocities of liquid and gas are regulated to provide an interface between said reaction mixture and said gaseous effluent discharging from said mixture and wherein liquid and gaseous effluents are removed from the reaction zone with some carryover of said particulate solids in said liquid effluent, the improvement which comprises: a. minimizing the carryover of particulate solids in said liquid effluent by first disengaging gaseous effluent from the gas-liquid-solid mixture below the interface to produce disengaged gas and dilute slurry; b. introducing the gas-free dilute slurry to a solids separation zone contained within the reaction zone, said separation zone comprising a vessel having a closed upper end with a discharge conduit from said end for passing liquid effluent to the exterior of said reaction zone, an opening in the bottom of said vessel for passing said gas-free dilute slurry into said vessel; c. removing a substantially solid-free liquid effluent from said operation zone at a rate whose linear velocity in the separation zone is less than the settling rate of the solids of the dilute slurry in the separation zone; d. settling the solids out of the dilute slurry to form a concentrated slurry in the lower part of the separation zone; e. removing said concentrated slurry from said separation zone and returning the slurry to the reaction zone; and f. separately removing gas from the upper part of said reaction zone and liquid effluent from the vessel through the discharge conduit out of the reaction zone. 